This page has been automatically translated. Please refer to the page in French if needed.
Co-ownership
Do you have to pay the same elevator charges on the ground floor and upstairs?
Publié le null - Directorate for Legal and Administrative Information (Prime Minister)
The distribution of maintenance and repair costs for the elevator in your building must take into account, in addition to the area of the lots, their location in the building and the theoretical usefulness of the service provided to each lot. Indeed, the use and usefulness of an elevator are not the same if you live at the 1er or 12e floor.
Thus, the clause of the co-ownership regulation which provides for equal shares of the elevator charges between lots located on different floors is null and void. This is what the Court of Cassation ruled in its decision of May 9, 2019.
A co-owner shall apply to the court for annulment of the clause of the co-ownership regulation relating to the elevator charges providing for equal distribution between lots. The Court of Appeal rules that the settlement clause is legal. The applicant's reasons for its decision are that the clause specifies the reasons for the decision to apply such a division and that the applicant does not demonstrate that the clause is contrary to the utility test.
The Court of Cassation annuls this decision. It considers that an equal distribution of lift loads between lots on different floors does not meet the utility criterion. This legal criterion provides that the common charges must be allocated according to their objective usefulness for each lot. Thus, the calculation of elevator charges must necessarily take into account the floor of each lot.
Additional topics
Service-Public.fr
Agenda
Aide au logement
À partir du 8 juil. 2024
Publié le 24 juin 2024
Plateforme Mon Master
Du 4 juin au 31 juil. 2024
Publié le 06 juin 2024
Lycéens
À partir du 1 sept. 2024
Publié le 23 mai 2024
Collégiens
À partir du 1 sept. 2024
Publié le 22 mai 2024