This page has been automatically translated. Please refer to the page in French if needed.
Civil liability
No fault can be blamed on the owners of a swimming pool left unattended or unprotected
Publié le 04 mai 2023 - Directorate for Legal and Administrative Information (Prime Minister)
You own a swimming pool. You wonder to what extent your civil liability could be incurred in the event of drowning. Sometimes, depending on the circumstances, no reckless mistake can be made. This is what the Court of Cassation states in a judgment of March 9, 2023.
A two-and-a-half-year-old child escapes parental supervision. He died after falling into an unprotected swimming pool on unenclosed land three houses from his home. Parents complain to landlords and demand compensation for carelessness. The father and mother of the child consider that the owners made a mistake by placing a simple tarpaulin over the swimming pool, which did not offer all the guarantees of safety against the risk of drowning.
The Criminal Court acquits the spouses of the charge of manslaughter and declares the parents’ civil party admissible. The Court of Appeal ruled that the couple who owned the swimming pool had no fault of their own and rejected the parents’ claim for compensation.
The Court of Cassation upholds the appeal judgment and dismisses the appeal brought by the parents. The couple cannot be blamed for any recklessness (failure to put a rigid tarpaulin back on after the pelvis was cleaned and failure to keep a constant watch). The owners of the swimming pool could not legitimately envisage a very young child entering their private property alone. They cannot therefore be held liable because there is no causal link between their behavior and the death of the child who was left unattended by his parents.
Additional topics
Service-Public.fr
Agenda
Prévention
Du 15 oct. 2024 au 31 janv. 2025
Publié le 30 octobre 2024
Lycéens
Jusqu'au 15 nov. 2024
Publié le 22 octobre 2024
Collégiens
Jusqu'au 15 nov. 2024
Publié le 22 octobre 2024
Sevrage tabagique
À partir du 1 nov. 2024
Publié le 15 octobre 2024