Wreck: what happens to the car that has been badly damaged?
Verified 24 October 2023 - Directorate for Legal and Administrative Information (Prime Minister)
You've had a serious traffic accident with your car ?
In view of the damage, the policy can declare your vehicle dangerous to traffic.
The insurance expert may also declare the vehicle unsafe after examination.
In the 2 cases, the vehicle is banned from circulation and it can no longer be sold or donated.
To put the vehicle back into circulation, you will have to follow a very strict procedure.
We present you what happens when the vehicle is declared dangerous by law enforcement and when it is declared dangerous by the expert.
By law enforcement
If you have an accident, the police officers police or gendarmerie may decide to immobilize your vehicle if they find that it represents a immediate danger for you and other road users.
This immobilization triggers damaged vehicle (VE) procedure. It involves removing a dangerous vehicle from the road.
Law enforcement officers have the right to you remove carte grise the certificate of registration (ex-) on the spot. They shall inform the Ministry of the Interior by electronic means.
Law enforcement officers must establish a notice of withdrawal.
You must receive a copy of this notice.
A copy is also sent by post to the Ministry of the Interior, together with the registration certificate.
If the agents couldn't pull you out the certificate of registration at the time of immobilization of the vehicle, they must inform the ministry of the interior.
Prohibition of circulation, sale and donation
The Ministry of the Interior will loose by registered letter that your vehicle is no longer allowed to circulate on the public road.
He writes a opposition to transfer the certificate of registration and, therefore, you can no longer sell the vehicle or give it to another person.
Obligation to carry out a confirmatory assessment
The vehicle shall be examined by a specially authorized expert for the ‘ VE procedure ”.
The expert is mandated by the insurer who will compensate you.
Its mission is to verify whether the vehicle is in good working order in normal safety conditions or not, and if he is technically repairable or not.
Deficiencies which may allow the expert to conclude that the vehicle is no longer in a condition to circulate in normal safety conditions are:
- Bodywork: significant deformation
- Failure of the elements between the anchoring zones of the connecting elements to the ground (side members, floor, wheel arches, chassis, cross members)
- Direction: large distortion
- Defect of the following elements: column, rack or housing, links and wheelhouse
- Ground connections: significant deformation
- Defect in cradle, suspension, axles and rims
- Personal safety: malfunction (including improper fixation)
- Defect in belts, airbags, pre-tensioners, control boxes
The expert shall state his conclusions in a expert report. It shall transmit it to the Ministry of the Interior by electronic means.
The expert shall also forward a copy of the report to the insurer which has authorized him.
You will be informed by the insurer of the conclusion of the expert report.
The remainder of the procedure depends on the conclusions of this report.
If the expert confirms that the vehicle is dangerous, he shall specify whether it is technically repairable or not.
The vehicle is technically repairable
If the expert considers that the vehicle is technically repairable, he shall specify in his report the descriptive and quantified repair list to be carried out by a professional of the automobile.
Where the expert considers that repair amount is greater than market value of vehicle, it must relate that information to the report.
The remainder of the procedure depends on whether the repair costs are higher than the market value of the car or not.
Répondez aux questions successives et les réponses s’afficheront automatiquement
Repair costs shall not exceed the value of the vehicle
The insurance will give you permission to have the vehicle repaired.
For to put the vehicle back into circulationNo, you have to repair by a professional.
Then you have to make validate repairs by a EV expert.
You can choose a different expert from the one who performed the first test.
Repair costs are higher than the value of the vehicle
The insurer will not give you permission to make the repairs.
In this case, the insurance must trigger the procedure " economically irreparable vehicle ”.
This is a procedure that allows them to buy back the damaged vehicle from you instead of paying for repairs.
This procedure can be deployed by the insurer who must compensate you following a serious accident.
If the market value of your vehicle is at least €152.45, the insurer must propose one redemption offer of the vehicle in the 15 days after the expert report has been submitted.
You must give your answer within 30 days following receipt of the insurer's offer to buy back.
1st case: you accept the insurer's repurchase offer
If you accept the insurer's proposal, you must complete the vehicle transfer certificate on behalf of the insurer.
Certificate of transfer of a second-hand vehicle
2nd case: you refuse the insurer's redemption offer or you do not respond
If you refuse the insurer's proposal or if you don't follow through within the 30 days upon receipt, the insurer must inform the ministry of interior and notify you by simple letter.
The insurer must transmit the information to the Ministry of the Interior by electronic channel, in 15 days following the date of your refusal (or within 15 days after the expiry of the 30 days during which you had to respond to his buyback proposal).
After being informed by the insurer, the Ministry of the Interior enters a opposition to any transfer carte grise the vehicle registration certificate (ex-vehicle) in the name of another person (sale or donation of the car to a third party).
The Ministry of the Interior must notify you by single letter of the entry of that opposition to transfer.
As a result, the vehicle can no longer be sold to an individual, but can be sold to a purchaser professional.
The professional buyer will be able to repair the car or destroy the carcass after recovering the spare parts.
If you wish to request the carte grise withdrawal of opposition to the transfer of, you must first order a new expertise of the vehicle, at your expense.
The Ministry of the Interior will be able to authorize the transfer and recirculation of the vehicle if the new expert report certifies that the safety work has been carried out by a professional and that the vehicle is safe to drive.
The vehicle is technically irreparable
If the expert finds that it is impossible to repair the vehicle by allowing it to travel with all its safety characteristics, he must declare it technically irreparable.
Shall be considered as technically irreparable vehicles which at least one of the 6 defects following:
- Vehicles completely burned; i.e. vehicles whose engine compartment and passenger compartment are destroyed
- Vehicles submerged above the dashboard
- Vehicles with a safety component which is neither repairable nor replaceable
- Vehicles in which all or part of the structural and safety components are affected by irreversible and non-replaceable technical defects (aging of metals, initiation of multiple breaks, excessive perforating corrosion, etc.)
- Vehicles whose repair requires the exchange of the engine-box and hull or chassis assembly which results in the loss of their original identity
- Vehicles which are definitively non-identifiable, after exhaustion of the means of research and of the steps enabling them to be identified
The expert must specify the defects found on your vehicle.
If the value of your vehicle is at least €152.45, the insurer responsible for your compensation must propose one redemption offer of the vehicle in the 15 days after the expert report has been submitted.
You must give your answer within 30 days following receipt of the insurer's offer to buy back.
The insurer must warn by electronic means the Ministry of the Interior so that it can prevent the transfer of the registration certificate carte grise (ex-person) on behalf of another person (sale or donation of the car to a third party).
The Ministry of the Interior must inform you by registered mail (with acknowledgement of receipt) that your vehicle is no longer allowed to circulate.
The mail must also indicate that you can no longer sell the vehicle, or give it away, unless it is to a demoliser who buys it for destruction.
The insurer in charge of your compensation must offer you an offer to buy back the vehicle within 15 days after receipt of the expert report.
If you accept this offer, the insurer will take care of the formalities of destruction of the vehicle.
If you refuse the offer of insurance, you keep your vehicle, but you can only sell (or give) it to a demoliser for destruction.
If the expert does not confirm that the vehicle is dangerous, the Ministry of the Interior must return the certificate of registration and it must to lift the opposition to the transfer.
You have to make a demand to the Ministry of the Interior and attach a identity document, one proof of domicile and the notice of withdrawal or certificate of delivery of the registration certificate.
You will be able to drive with the vehicle again and sell or give it away, after the return of the registration certificate and the lifting of the opposition to the transfer by the Ministry of the Interior.
By the expert
If you have had a serious accident, the insurance company that must compensate you will appoint an expert to assess the cost of repairs.
If the expert notewhen examining your vehicle, that it has at least one serious disability that prevents it from traveling in normal safety conditions., he must inform the Ministry of the Interior.
Deficiencies which may allow the expert to conclude that the vehicle is no longer in a condition to circulate in normal safety conditions are:
- Bodywork: significant deformation
- Failure of the elements between the anchoring zones of the connecting elements to the ground (side members, floor, wheel arches, chassis, cross members)
- Direction: large distortion
- Defect of the following elements: column, rack or housing, links and wheelhouse
- Ground connections: significant deformation
- Defect in cradle, suspension, axles and rims
- Personal safety: malfunction (including improper fixation)
- Defect in belts, airbags, pre-tensioners, control boxes
The expert must submit an electronic report to the Minister of the Interior for theinform that the vehicle is dangerous to traffic.
It must specify the serious deficiencies which he found on the vehicle.
The expert shall also indicate in his declaration whether the vehicle is technically repairable or not.
The expert must send you a copy of the declaration by post.
The expert report triggers the procedure damaged vehicle (VE), which consists in removing a dangerous vehicle from circulation.
Prohibition of circulation and sale
After receiving the expert's statement, the Ministry of the Interior will loose by registered letter that your vehicle is no longer allowed to circulate on the public road.
The Ministry of the Interior registers a opposition to transfer the certificate of registration and, therefore, you can no longer sell the vehicle or give it to another person.
Drafting of the first expert report
After the declaration of danger of the vehicle, the expert shall draw up a first report without removing the vehicle.
At the end of this first report he shall indicate whether the vehicle is technically repairable.
If the expert concludes that the vehicle is technically repairable, he shall add as an annex to his report the list and cost of repairs to be carried out, indicating those affecting the safety of the vehicle.
If it finds that the repair amount is greater than market value of vehicle, he must state that in the report.
If the expert concludes that the vehicle is technically irreparable, it must specify the criteria of technical irreparability which it has identified.
Shall be considered as technically irreparable vehicles which at least one of the 6 defects following:
- Vehicles completely burned; i.e. vehicles whose engine compartment and passenger compartment are destroyed
- Vehicles submerged above the dashboard
- Vehicles with a safety component which is neither repairable nor replaceable
- Vehicles in which all or part of the structural and safety components are affected by irreversible and non-replaceable technical defects (aging of metals, initiation of multiple breaks, excessive perforating corrosion, etc.)
- Vehicles whose repair requires the exchange of the engine-box and hull or chassis assembly which results in the loss of their original identity
- Vehicles which are definitively non-identifiable, after exhaustion of the means of research and of the steps enabling them to be identified
The expert must send you the report by mail.
It must also transmit it electronically to the Ministry of the Interior.
The remainder of the procedure depends on the conclusions of this first report.
If the first report concludes that the vehicle is technically repairable, the remainder of the procedure depends on whether the expert has indicated that the repair costs are higher than the market value of the car or not.
Repair costs shall not exceed the market value of the car
If the repair costs do not exceed the market value of the car, you can repair the vehicle and ask to put it back into service.
But you have to entrust the reparation to one professional garage owner and mandate a EV expert to track repair work.
The EV expert must prepare a report at the end of the work.
This is the second report.
You can choose a different expert from the one who performed the first test.
The expert you have commissioned must read the first report expertise and ensure that repairs are carried out according to recommendations it contains.
If the expert considers that the repairs have been carried out in accordance with the recommendations of the first report and that the vehicle is in a condition for operation under normal safety conditions, his report shall contain the following elements:
- Technical characteristics of vehicle
- Name and address of the owner who commissioned it
- Name and approval number of the expert on the national list
- References of 1er report (date, name and address of the firm, name and approval number of the expert who prepared it)
- Different phases of follow-up of the repair check and quality of persons present
- Confirmation that the safety repairs provided for in 1er reports have been completed successfully
- Confirmation that the vehicle is safe to drive
- Carte grise Confirmation that the vehicle has not undergone any significant transformation or that the elements contained in the
The expert who prepared the second report must send it to you at the same time as to the Minister of the Interior.
Based on this second report, you can ask the Ministry of the Interior for the lifting of the driving ban and the opposition to transfer the certificate of registration.
You can also request the surrender or reissue of the registration certificate.
You must attach a identity document, one proof of domicile and the notice of withdrawal of the certificate of registration.
You can drive the vehicle again and sell or give it away, if the Ministry of Interior agrees to lift the bans and return the registration certificate.
Repair costs are higher than the market value of the car
If the expert has indicated in the first report that the repair costs are greater than market value the vehicle, the insurer must refuse to repair the vehicle.
In this case, it must trigger the procedure " economically irreparable vehicle ”.
This is a procedure that allows the insurer to buy back the damaged vehicle from you instead of paying for repairs.
This procedure can be deployed by the insurer who must compensate you following a serious accident.
If the value of your vehicle is at least €152.45, the insurer must propose one redemption offer of the vehicle in the 15 days after the expert report has been submitted.
You must give your answer within 30 days following receipt of the insurer's offer to buy back.
Répondez aux questions successives et les réponses s’afficheront automatiquement
You accept the insurer's redemption offer
If you accept the insurer's proposal, you must complete the vehicle transfer certificate on behalf of the insurer.
Certificate of transfer of a second-hand vehicle
Carte grise You must send the certificate of transfer accompanied by the certificate of registration (ex-) to the insurer.
The insurance will pay you the price mentioned in the offer.
You refuse the insurer's redemption offer or you do not respond
If you refuse the insurer's proposal or if you don't follow through within the 30 days upon receipt, the insurer must inform the ministry of interior and notify you by simple letter.
The insurer must transmit the information to the Ministry of the Interior by electronic channel, in 15 days following the date of your refusal, or in the 15 days after the expiry of the 30 days during which you had to respond to his buyback proposal.
After being informed by the insurer, the Ministry of the Interior enters a opposition to any transfer carte grise the vehicle registration certificate (ex-vehicle) in the name of another person (sale or donation of the car to a third party).
The Ministry of the Interior must notify you by single letter of the entry of that opposition to transfer.
As a result, the vehicle can no longer be sold to an individual, but can be sold to a purchaser professional.
The professional buyer will be able to repair the car or destroy the carcass after recovering the spare parts.
If the expert finds that it is impossible to repair the vehicle by allowing it to travel with all its safety characteristics, he must declare it technically irreparable.
If the expert concludes that the vehicle is technically repairable, he shall state this in the report and specify the criteria of irreparability which he has identified.
Shall be considered as technically irreparable vehicles which at least one of the 6 defects following:
- Vehicles completely burned; i.e. vehicles whose engine compartment and passenger compartment are destroyed
- Vehicles submerged above the dashboard
- Vehicles with a safety component which is neither repairable nor replaceable
- Vehicles in which all or part of the structural and safety components are affected by irreversible and non-replaceable technical defects (aging of metals, initiation of multiple breaks, excessive perforating corrosion, etc.)
- Vehicles whose repair requires the exchange of the engine-box and hull or chassis assembly which results in the loss of their original identity
- Vehicles which are definitively non-identifiable, after exhaustion of the means of research and of the steps enabling them to be identified
If the value of your vehicle is at least €152.45, the insurer responsible for your compensation must propose one redemption offer of the vehicle in the 15 days after the expert report has been submitted.
You must give your answer within 30 days following receipt of the insurer's offer to buy back.
If you accept this offer, the insurer will take care of the formalities of the destruction of the vehicle.
If you refuse the insurance proposal, the insurer must warn by electronic means the Ministry of the Interior.
The Ministry of the Interior take a decision opposing the transfer of the registration certificate carte grise (ex-person) on behalf of another person (sale or donation of the car to a third party).
The Ministry of the Interior must inform you by registered mail with notice of receipt that your vehicle is no longer allowed to circulate.
The mail must also indicate that you can no longer sell the vehicle, or give it away, unless it is to a demoliser who buys it for destruction.
Who can help me?
Find who can answer your questions in your region
Damaged vehicles and economically irreparable vehicles
Damaged Vehicle Procedure
Damaged Vehicle Procedure
Service-Public.fr
Supervisory and Resolution Authority (ACPR)